A Queensland judge ruled that strict conditions can protect the community from Sterling Mervyn Free, 35, who will leave prison on 9 December. Psychiatrists assessed his risk of reoffending as “moderate to high” without supervision.
A man who abducted a seven-year-old girl from a Kmart toy aisle near Brisbane and sexually assaulted her in remote bushland is due to be released from prison within weeks. Sterling Mervyn Free, 35, has served almost eight years for the December 2018 attack, which shocked Australia. Justice Kerri Mellifont ruled in the Queensland Supreme Court on Monday that he should be freed on 9 December under a 10-year supervision order. She said she was satisfied that the “extremely strict and expansive range of conditions” would adequately protect the community. The girl’s family and supporters were in court, and one supporter described the decision as “absolutely disgusting” as they left, The Courier-Mail reported.
The ruling
Psychiatrists told the court Free posed a “moderate to high” risk of reoffending, which could fall to “low moderate” with supervision and strict conditions. The court heard he had completed sex offender treatment programmes in prison and showed “good prospects of compliance”.
Justice Mellifont noted that the Attorney-General maintained her primary position that a continuing detention order should be made. She said: “I have formed the view that the extremely strict and expansive range of conditions proposed … are sufficient so as to adequately protect the community.” She added that the “expert opinion of very experienced psychiatrists is that the risk can be reduced to a manageable level in the context of compliance with the requirements of a supervision order”. News.com.au reported that she told Free there would be “absolutely no excuses” for failing to comply.
Free appeared by videolink from prison. He asked how long the supervision order would last, then thanked the judge. ABC News reported that he took notes and otherwise stayed largely silent, showing little visible emotion.
Conditions of release
Under the order, Free will be subject to dozens of conditions. They include a ban on attending shopping centres outside school hours, although ABC News reported that he may enter them outside school hours if Queensland Corrective Services gives permission, so the ban is not absolute. He must also undergo ongoing specialised treatment and therapy.
Medication to suppress sexual urges was “recommended”, but Free “can’t be forced to take it”. ABC reported that he had attended an initial medical consultation but had not agreed to treatment. If he starts the medication, regular blood tests would monitor compliance and its effect on suppressing testosterone. ABC also reported that the hearing was told he had been diagnosed with paedophilia, antisocial personality disorder, substance abuse disorder and pornography addiction, and that his childhood trauma and impulsive behaviour were discussed.
A full written ruling confirming every condition, including whether he must wear a GPS tracker, where he will live or any curfew, has not been made public. Those details should not be attributed to him without the order.
Queensland’s Dangerous Prisoners (Sexual Offenders) Act 2003 sets requirements that apply to supervised offenders in general. They include reporting to corrective services officers and accepting visits, giving at least two business days’ notice of any change of address, employment or name, and not leaving Queensland without permission. Courts can add measures such as location-monitoring devices and limits on contact with other sex offenders.
Breaching a supervision order without reasonable excuse is an offence carrying up to two years in prison. Deliberately tampering with a monitoring device carries up to five years and a minimum one-year sentence. Officers can seek an arrest warrant if they reasonably suspect a supervised offender is likely to breach, is breaching or has breached a condition. After an established breach, the Supreme Court must revoke the order and impose continuing detention unless the offender can persuade it that the public can still be protected through amended supervision.
The release is not ordinary parole. The proceedings fall under the 2003 Act, which allows continued detention or supervised release beyond the original sentence, and makes protecting the community the paramount consideration. The law also allows a further supervision order once an existing one expires, so restrictions could continue beyond about December 2036, though that would need a separate legal process.
The 2018 abduction
The girl was in Kmart at Westfield North Lakes with her mother, shopping for Christmas presents. Free, then 27 and a father of two, lured her from the store and drove her to Pumicestone Passage, where he assaulted her. He returned her to the shopping centre almost 90 minutes later.
He pleaded guilty to taking a child for immoral purposes, deprivation of liberty, and indecent treatment of a child under 12. In October 2019, he received an eight-year prison sentence, with 306 days already served in custody counted towards it, ABC News reported. Judge Julie Dick described CCTV footage of him taking the child out of the store as evidence of predatory and opportunistic conduct involving some premeditation, and called the offence “every parent’s nightmare”. She said Free told police he had experienced sexual fantasies about young girls before but claimed he had never acted on them. That is his claim and was not independently established by the court.
At the time, the girl’s mother said her daughter was “well aware of stranger danger, however this person was friendly to her and tricked her into following him”. “No child should ever have to go through this type of trauma, and no sentence will ever be long enough to make up for the ongoing effects this will have on her,” she said. “We, as a family, remain positive and are trying to move forward.”
The sentence appeal
The sentence set an early parole eligibility date in 2021. Queensland’s then Attorney-General, Yvette D’Ath, announced an appeal in Parliament on 24 October 2019 after advice from the Director of Public Prosecutions, describing the sentence as manifestly inadequate. She did not challenge the eight-year term itself. The appeal focused on when Free could apply for parole, with prosecutors arguing that the judge should have withheld the early eligibility date or declared the kidnapping a serious violent offence, which could have meant serving 80% of the sentence.
The Court of Appeal decided on 31 March 2020, in a 24-page judgment. It kept the eight-year sentence but removed the early eligibility date, so Free had to serve half before he could apply. The judges stressed community protection, saying the mitigating effects of a guilty plea and co-operation had to be balanced against the seriousness of the offending, and that it was not yet known how he would respond to treatment in prison.
Thousands of Australians signed a petition calling for an appeal at the time, according to The Noticer. It reported that former Home Affairs Minister Peter Dutton called the original sentence “grossly inadequate”.
